What Went Wrong?: Western Impact and Middle Eastern Response
What Went Wrong?: Western Impact and Middle Eastern Response by Bernard Lewis is a seminal work exploring the complex relationship between the West and the Middle East over the past two centuries. Lewis argues that the West's attempts to impose its values and institutions on the Middle East have led to a clash of civilizations, resulting in instability, conflict, and mutual misunderstanding.
Lewis begins by examining the history of Western imperialism in the Middle East, tracing its roots back to the Crusades and the European colonization of the region in the 19th and 20th centuries. He argues that Western powers have consistently sought to dominate the Middle East for economic, strategic, and religious reasons, often with disastrous consequences for the region.
Lewis then turns his attention to the Middle Eastern response to Western imperialism. He argues that the region's traditional elites, such as the Ottoman Empire and the Arab monarchies, were unable to effectively resist Western encroachment, leading to their eventual collapse. In the aftermath of colonialism, the Middle East was left fragmented and vulnerable, creating fertile ground for the rise of radical ideologies, such as pan-Arabism and Islamism.
Lewis concludes by arguing that the West and the Middle East need to find a new way to coexist. He calls for a dialogue between the two civilizations, based on mutual respect and understanding. He also emphasizes the need for the West to be more sensitive to the concerns and aspirations of the Middle East, and to avoid imposing its own values and institutions on the region.
What Went Wrong? is a thought-provoking and controversial book that has sparked a great deal of debate among scholars and policymakers. It is a must-read for anyone interested in understanding the complex relationship between the West and the Middle East.
Rating: